Henrietta’s face went white under all that makeup. “Rufus,” she hissed. “Sit down. You’ve had too much champagne.” “I’ve had one glass,” he said calmly. “And I’ve waited fifty years

Comments Off on Henrietta’s face went white under all that makeup. “Rufus,” she hissed. “Sit down. You’ve had too much champagne.” “I’ve had one glass,” he said calmly. “And I’ve waited fifty years

PART 2

Henrietta’s face went white under all that makeup.

“Rufus,” she hissed. “Sit down. You’ve had too much champagne.” “I’ve had one glass,” he said calmly. “And I’ve waited fifty years.”

Etta looked up at me. I took her hand, and we walked out of the kitchen together. Every head in that ballroom turned.

Rufus pulled out the chair next to him at the head table. Etta climbed into it.

Then he turned to the room.

“When I met Henrietta,” he said, “she was nineteen. She worked at the soda fountain on Broad Street. She had the most beautiful laugh I’d ever heard. And she had a birthmark.”

A murmur went through the room.

“Right here.” He touched the left side of his own face. “Purple. From her eye to her jaw. Just like Etta’s.”

Henrietta covered her mouth with her hand.

“Her mother made her hide it,” Rufus said. “She was told she’d never get married with a face like that. She was told to stay in the back of the shop so customers wouldn’t see her. She was told she was something to be ashamed of.”

His voice got softer.

“I married her anyway. Because she was the most wonderful person I had ever met. But she never believed me. She’s worn heavy makeup every single day for fifty years. Even to bed. I haven’t seen my own wife’s face since 1976.”

The room was completely silent.

“And now,” Rufus said, his voice shaking, “she’s doing to our granddaughter exactly what her mother did to her.”

Tears were running down Henrietta’s cheeks. Her makeup was streaking.

And underneath it, on the left side of her face, I could see it.

Faded with age. But still there.

A purple mark.

Etta saw it too. She stared at her grandmother for a long moment.

Then she climbed down from her chair, walked over to Henrietta, and took her hand.

“Grandma,” she said. “You have one too?”

Henrietta couldn’t speak. She just nodded.

Etta smiled.

“Mine’s on the right,” she said. “Yours is on the left. So we match.”

Henrietta made a sound I’d never heard from her. A broken, terrible sob. She dropped to her knees on that ballroom floor, in her pearls and her silk dress, and held my daughter.

“I’m so sorry,” she cried. “I’m so sorry, baby. I’m so sorry.”

Nobody said anything for a long time.

Then the older man from the kitchen, the one who’d brought Etta her cookie, started clapping. Then the string quartet. Then everyone.

After the party, Henrietta asked if she could talk to me alone.

“I treated her the way I was treated,” she said. “I thought I was protecting her. I was really just protecting myself.”

Over the next few months, she changed. Slowly. She started coming to Etta’s laser treatments, holding her hand. She put Etta on the front of her Christmas card. Front and center.

And in March, on a sunny Sunday morning, she came to church without any makeup at all.

People stared.

She lifted her chin and walked straight to the front pew with Etta beside her.

Now they have a little tradition. Every Sunday, before church, Etta looks at her grandmother’s face and says the same thing.

“We still match, Grandma.”

And Henrietta always answers.

“We always will.”

THE END.